Tuesday, June 24, 2008

The opposite of dissemination: suppression

When thinking about potential dissemination issues, the thought of Sports Illustrated, never entered my mind as being a potential ethical issue. In 2007, Sports Illustrated decided to hold back 21,000 copies of their swimsuit edition to classrooms and libraries, which needless to say made a number of librarians angry, after all, a lot of people like Sports Illustrated (especially the swimsuit edition). Instead of letting libraries opt out of receiving the magazine, they made the decision (on their own) to withhold it. It wasn’t until the national news picked up the story did they offer to correct their mistake and invited the neglected libraries to request their copy (Oder, 2007).

Censorship is a concern in all libraries and even in the traditional classroom. A teacher was recently suspended and faced possible criminal charges after he let a minor student select Child of God, a novel written by Cormac McCarthy (a Pulitzer Prize winning author, by the way), off a suggested reading list, because the novel contained controversial and graphic references (Brown, 2007). Some parents welcomed the teacher’s reinstatement. Others did not, and one even filed a police report against the teacher (Brown, 2007). What do these actions say about our society?

Ferris (2007) details the ALA’s approach to censorship as “the suppression of ideas and information that certain persons….find objectionable or dangerous” (p. 33). Regardless of this, it is the role of the library professional to ensure their beliefs, values, opinions, etc do not intercede the mission of providing access to information. Since librarians do have a responsibility to serve as educators and as an information resource, eliminating a book, newspaper, magazine, video, DVD, etc, that opposes their viewpoint or belief, makes them censors. Regardless, if a librarian has a strong opinion on a topic, they cannot hold back a book that is a proponent of that topic (or vice versa). It is against their mission as an information professional to engage in this behavior.

As a child, I remember reading, Are you there god, it’s me, Margaret? This book answered a lot of questions about growing up and cleared up a lot of confusion. This book is (and has been) banned from many school libraries because of its controversial subjects: religion, sex, divorce, and puberty. The last week of September, libraries hold Banned Books Week, to address this censorship threat. Although, many books are more “challenged…not actually banned” (Long, 2006, p. 73). In 2006, the “American Library Association was notified of 547 challenges, up from 459” (Long, 2006, p. 73) the previous year. As long as people have opinions and beliefs, this will also be a challenge to library professionals in all types of libraries and there will always be suppression problems like these.

Citations

Brown, A. K. (2007, October 22). Teacher put on leave after book complaint. Star-Telegram.

Fallis, D.(2007). Information ethics for twenty-first century library professionals. Library Hi Tech, 25 (1), 23-36

Long. S. (2006) Banned Books Week: a celebration of intellectual freedom. New Library World, 107 (1220/1221), 73-75.

Oder, N. Swimsuit Issue Denied to Libraries. Library Journal (1976) v. 132 no. 6 (April 1 2007) p. 14-15

Thursday, June 19, 2008

The power of Creative Commons

There is a fantastic tool for librarians and information science professionals. But first for a ilttle background. According to their website, Creative Commons is a nonprofit organization that helps people protect their work, while sharing it. Essentially, it is

On this site, I have taken the pictures or used pictures through a creative commons source like Flickr (rather than Google images, which takes pictures from websites, which might have copyrighted or restricted images and aren't free to use). However, pictures from Flickr are free to use.

Only one more post on information policies, I promise

According to ALA Intellectual Freedom Manual, intellectual freedom can only exist through the following:

“Intellectual freedom can exist only where two essential conditions are met: first, that all
individuals have the right to hold any belief on any subject and to convey their ideas in any form they deem appropriate; and second, that society makes an equal commitment to the right of unrestricted access to information and ideas regardless of the communication
medium used, the content of the work, and the viewpoints of both the author and receiver of information. Freedom to express oneself through a chosen mode of communication, including the Internet, becomes virtually meaningless if access to that information is not protected. Intellectual freedom implies a circle, and that circle is broken if either freedom of expression or access to ideas is stifled.”

This means several things for libraries, since they exist to help people achieve intellectual freedom. We are living in a technological age, where immediate information is readily available to people who know how to find it. Unfortunately, not everyone has the financial ability (or desire) to partake in this. D’Elia, Jörgensen, Woelfel and Rodger (2002) studied internet use in public libraries and the effect on library utilization. While this article is dated, is does provide an interesting viewpoint. D’Elia et al (2002) surveyed library utilization and why people make decisions to not have the Internet. In 2002, a significant percentage claimed the expense and privacy concerns with not wanting to engage in Internet searches. This behavior and belief has, of course, changed, but many people still seek out personal computers and the Internet at their local library.

Currently, there is a concentrated focus on the establishment of Internet policies that govern how libraries provide Internet service to its patrons. Federal mandates and legislation, “have made some type of filtering mandatory” (Rubin, 2004, p. 194) in cases where libraries receive federal monies. Filters block content or block certain websites. However, this could lead to some legitimate websites also being blocked from a search. A student searching for information on “breast cancer” as a classmate recently explained, could possibly result in significant blocking due to the sexual term “breast”. The American Library Association has taken a stand against filters and has passed resolutions and policies regarding filtering. This is important to the ALA since “filters in fact deprive both young people and adults of constitutionally protected speech and that libraries have a special obligation to protect such access” (Rubin, 2004, p. 200).

Does this change the way information is disseminated by library and information science professionals?

Citations

D’Elia, G., Jörgensen, C., Woelfel, J., Rodger, E. (2002). The impact of the Internet on public
library use: An analysis of the current consumer market for library and Internet services. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology. 53(10), 802-820.

Rubin, R.E. (2004). Foundations of library and information science. New York: Neal-Schuman.

Wednesday, June 18, 2008

Library ethics, patron privacy…is this related to dissemination?

The term “ethics” is a difficult one to easily define. A simplistic way to look at it, is analyzing the difference between right and wrong. Of course, everyone will have varied ways to approach a situation and a difficult ethical issue for one person, would be a simple decision for another. When consulting the American Library Association’s Code of Ethics, it explains “The principles of this Code are expressed in broad statements to guide ethical decision making. These statements provide a framework; they cannot and do not dictate conduct to cover particular situations” (American Library Association website). A Code of Ethics can only provide a basic “framework” and cannot tell someone how to behave or exactly what decisions to make. Therefore, it is essential for professionals to be aware of the potential ethical issues they may face in their chosen career path.

Core to the ALA’s Code of Ethics is the following statement “We protect each library user's right to privacy and confidentiality with respect to information sought or received and resources consulted, borrowed, acquired or transmitted” (www.ala.org). Library patrons should never be in fear that their information will be given to any third party. In our recent culture, unfortunately, and somewhat understandably, we are in a time and place, where this can become a very heated, political and ethical argument. This has become such an important issue, the American Libraries journal included an insert detailing a model policy on how to respond to demands for library records, “Responding to Demands for Library Records”. With the passage of the Patriot Act, and discussion on the FBI’s use and misuse of this policy to gain records, this will continue to be an issue that is difficult for people to agree.

Why is this important to the field of dissemination? Since libraries and information science professionals are actively engaged ensuring their information is shared with others, people should also have an expectation of privacy when taking advantage of these resources and services.

“Privacy has become a particularly important information policy issue for libraries because of governmental attempts to obtain borrowing information on individuals though their circulation records” (Rubin, 2004, p. 126). Many states have enacted state statutes that protect against “third-party access to borrowers’ records, while still providing limited access by governmental agencies for specific reasons” (Rubin, 2004, p. 126).

This is an issue that all libraries can face and one that can have detrimental effects from both sides. Failure of a library to comply with a court order to release information could result in libraries losing state or federal funding. Compliance could result in losing faith and confidence from library patrons. Either way, libraries should clearly share with their patrons their policies and procedures, in a public place and on their website.

Citations
Rubin, R.E. (2004). Foundations of library and information science. New York: Neal-Schuman.

Sunday, June 15, 2008

Information policy, library blogs and dissemination


Information policies help dictate and guide what kind of information can be disseminated and accessed (Lester and Koehler, 2007). This is mostly in relation to information produced by the government, "access to information in the private sector and government access to personal information" (Lester and Koehler, 2007, p. 308).

Current policies favor wide access to information, especially as it relates to government information. Information should be easily obtained and without restriction to anyone wanting it (Lester and Koehler, 2007). However, there are restrictions on this, to an extent.

False or misleading information, slanderous or libelous, obscene and personal information all have restriction on dissemination. Information that may "imperil or threaten national security" (Lester and Koehler, 2007, p. 308) also faces strict restrictions. When looked at with a common sense and logical approach, all of these make sense. Information that is false, misleading, personal or obscene should not be disseminated by information professionals, unless they are itching for a lawsuit.

Bloggers are also facing challenges to this. A recent Associated Press article discussed the challenges facing bloggers and lawsuits faced by some bloggers because of their dissemination of information. According to the article, "more than 100 judgments valued at $17 million have been handed down against bloggers over the last three years" (Rousseau, 2008).

So while blogging is an important outreach tools for librarians and information science professionals, careful attention to information policies and the proper dissemination of information is paramount.

Citations
Rousseau (2008, June 13). Training held bloggers hone professionalism. Associated Press. Retrieved: http://ap.google.com/article/ALeqM5jDcycDsY5menjjbjiq_hZf60NqqwD919LS800

Academic libraries and outreach: A look at Virgina Tech

In 2004,Virgina Tech took a proactive approach to organizing and structuring their marketing and library services and hired an Outreach Librarian (Vielle, 2006). The individual assigned to this position would be responsible for developing and implementing programs, special and events and representing the library and various external and internal events and programs (Vielle, 2006). The Outreach Librarian would also be responsible for providing tours of the library and conducting and developing surveys and holding focus groups to help determine the library patron needs (Vielle, 2006).

This proactive approach is important as it relates to information science dissemination, since dissemination is essentially a public relations and community outreach tool. How libraries approach can potentially help increase patrons use and understanding of the library’s services and role they play, especially when thinking about an academic library.

Vielle, L. (2006). The Best Is Yet to Come: Laying a Foundation for Marketing. Technical Services Quarterly. 24(2), 9-26.

Thursday, June 12, 2008

Outreach and dissemination

In my previous life, before moving to Gainesville, I worked in the Community Awareness Division at the St. Petersburg Police Department. Here we were responsible for the dissemination of all information to the media, citizens of St. Petersburg, and the employees of the police department. We did this in several ways, through press releases, newsletters, brochures, press conferences, presentation, and even through general conversations.

One of the first thoughts, when I think of dissemination tactics in information science and libraries is the potential focus on community outreach and public relations. Many libraries now have weblogs that help them spread information. Many libraries, including the local library here in Alachua County have an employee (or more than one) devoted to Community Outreach and a section on their website that concentrates on news releases. Some libraries also have podcasts, which help them reach their patrons easily obtain information about their library and potential special services.

Can libraries use these types of activities to disseminate information? I think so!